Parsha Toldos 5787 - Communication in Marriage
Nov 13
4 min read

The central part of this week's parsha describes how Yaakov received the blessing that Yitzchak had intended to give Esav. The Torah relates that Rivka overheard Yitzchak's conversation with Esav and devised a plan to enable Yaakov to disguise himself as Esav and receive the blessing. Rivka instructed Yaakov:
“Go now to the flock and fetch me from there two choice young kids of the goats, and I will make of them delicacies for your father, as he loves. Then bring it to your father and he shall eat, so that he may bless you before his death.” (Bereishis 27:9–10)
As Rabbi Jonathan Sacks points out, Rivka's plan presented serious ethical difficulties. It required her to deceive her husband, to deprive Esav of the blessing that Yitzchak intended to give him, and to instruct Yaakov to mislead his own father.
This raises an essential question: Why did Rivka believe that this deception was necessary? Why didn't she simply discuss the matter with Yitzchak and explain that, in her understanding, giving the blessing to Esav was contrary to Hashem's will? Why did she feel compelled to act behind her husband's back rather than openly express her concerns?
The question becomes even more troubling when we consider the consequences of what transpired. Although Rivka's plan succeeded in securing the blessing for Yaakov, the events had painful repercussions for the entire family and, ultimately, for Jewish history.
1) Yitzchak was extremely agitated, and “trembled very exceedingly.” (27:33). Rashi quotes a Midrash that Yitzchak saw Gehinnom open beneath him. (27:30).
2) Esav hated Yaakov and plotted to kill him. (Beraishis 27:41).
3) We don’t see that Rivka ever saw her beloved son Yaakov again after he fled to Charan.
4) After fleeing to Charan, Yaakov was repeatedly deceived by Lavan, most notably when Lavan substituted Leah for Rachel on the night of Yaakov's wedding (Bereishis 29:26; see Tanchuma, Vayetze 11).
5) Esav’s “exceedingly great and bitter cry” (27:34) reverberated throughout Jewish history, resulting in Mordechai’s “loud and bitter cry” (Esther 4:1) in response to Haman’s decree to eradicate the Jewish people. (Beraishis Rabbah 67:4). Indeed, the conflict between the Jewish people and the Romans (later the Christians) may have stemmed from the struggle between their ancestors Yaakov and Esav. (See Beraishis Rabba 99:4).
These consequences make the original question even more pressing. Why didn't Rivka communicate openly with Yitzchak?
To understand this, we must go back to last week's parsha, where the Torah describes Rivka's first encounter with her future husband, Yitzchak:
“And Rivka raised her eyes and saw Yitzchak; she alighted from the camel. And she said to the servant, ‘Who is that man walking in the field toward us?’ And the servant said, ‘He is my master.’ She then took the veil and covered herself.” (Bereishis 24:64–65)
The Netziv offers a fascinating explanation of Rivka's reaction. He understands that when Rivka first saw Yitzchak, she was overwhelmed by the holiness of this extraordinary man. The Torah uses the expression ותפול—literally, “she fell”—to describe her reaction as she descended from the camel. According to the Netziv, her response reflected the tremendous awe she felt in his presence.
That initial impression had a lasting effect on their relationship. Rivka regarded Yitzchak with such reverence that she found it difficult to openly disagree with him. Unlike Sarah with Avraham, or Rochel with Yaakov, who were not shy about rebuking their husbands, Rivka was reluctant to challenge her husband, even when she believed that he was making a serious mistake.
Rivkah alone had received a prophecy that the older should serve the younger (25:23), and therefore that Yaakov, rather than Esav, was the appropriate recipient of the blessings. After overhearing her husband offer to give the berachos to Esav, she determined that now was the time to act on that prophecy. However, as the Netziv explains, Rivka was reluctant to approach Yitzchak and explain her position. Instead, she devised a plan to bring about what she understood needed to happen. The Netziv understands that this entire sequence of events was part of Hashem's providence.
Nevertheless, my friend and colleague, Rabbi Mat Hoffman, who is also a well-known marriage counselor, draws an important practical lesson about marriage from this episode. One of the foundations of a successful marriage is open communication. A husband and wife may love and respect one another deeply, but if one spouse feels unable to express a disagreement or raise a difficult issue, that relationship can suffer.
Communication is essential not only for maintaining the relationship between husband and wife, but also for the well-being of the entire family. As we see from the events of this parsha, when important issues are not discussed openly, the consequences can extend far beyond the original disagreement.
This idea is independently echoed by Rav Avrohom Pam, ZT”L and Rabbi Jonathan Sacks. Rabbi Sacks discusses this episode in his essay “The Tragedy of Good Intentions” (Toldot 5772, 5785). A strong marriage must be built on honesty and openness. Even when the truth is uncomfortable, spouses need to be able to share their thoughts and concerns with one another. Good intentions alone are not enough; a healthy relationship requires the willingness to communicate.
We all strive to love our spouses but there is no marriage where spouses will always agree with each other. When disagreements inevitably occur, we should not be hesitant to respectfully speak with our spouse and mutually work out issues and arrive at a consensus. When we respectfully communicate, the Shalom Bayis, peace between husband and wife, radiates out to bring peace and harmony to the entire family, and by implication, to the entire world.
-Rabbi Garber 11/13/26





















Comments