Parshas Vayetze 5787 - Validation
14 minutes ago
4 min read

The Torah tells us that after Leah had given birth to four sons while Rochel remained childless, Rochel had the following exchange with Yaakov:
“Rochel saw that she had not borne children to Yaakov, so Rochel became envious of her sister; she said to Yaakov, ‘Give me children—otherwise I am dead.’ Yaakov's anger flared up at Rochel, and he said, ‘Am I instead of G-d, Who has withheld from you fruit of the womb?’” (Bereishis 30:1–2)
According to the Ramban and other commentators, when Rochel said to Yaakov, “Give me children,” she was expressing her frustration that Yaakov had not prayed sufficiently on her behalf. Yaakov became angry because he felt that Rochel misunderstood the nature of prayer. He responded that he was not responsible for her childlessness. Of course, he had prayed for his beloved Rochel to have children, but ultimately, no matter how much a person prays, he cannot compel Hashem to grant his wishes.
Nevertheless, Chazal were critical of the manner in which Yaakov responded to Rochel:
“The Torah states: ‘And Yaakov's anger was kindled.’ Said the Holy One, blessed be He, to him: ‘Is this the way to answer the troubled? By your life, your sons are destined to stand before hers.’” (Bereishis Rabbah 71:7)
The Maharzu (Rabbi Ze'ev Wolf Einhorn, 1780–1862) explains that because Yaakov spoke so harshly to Rochel, using the words “Am I instead of G-d?”, he would eventually experience a measure-for-measure consequence. His sons would one day stand before Rochel's son, Yosef, who would use those very same words: “Am I instead of G-d?” (Bereishis 50:19).
What is the connection between these two incidents? Why did the Midrash specifically connect Yaakov's response to Rochel with Yosef's later response to his brothers?
Yaakov used the words “Am I instead of G-d?” to rebuke his wife and defend himself against her complaint. In doing so, he failed to recognize the tremendous emotional pain that Rochel was experiencing. She had watched her sister Leah give birth to four sons while she herself remained childless. Rather than first acknowledging her distress and comforting her, Yaakov responded by explaining why her complaint was unjustified.
The consequences of this lack of sensitivity became apparent many years later. After Yaakov's death, Yosef's brothers became frightened that he might finally take revenge against them for having sold him into slavery many years earlier. They approached Yosef, fearful of what he might do to them now that their father was no longer alive to protect them.
Yosef responded:
“Am I instead of G-d? Although you intended me harm, G-d intended it for good… that a vast people be kept alive” (Bereishis 50:19–20)
Yosef could have reacted angrily. He could have questioned why his brothers still suspected him of seeking revenge after all he had done for them. Instead, he recognized their fear and responded with humility and compassion. He reassured them that they had no reason to be afraid and explained that Hashem had transformed their terrible actions into an opportunity to save many lives.
The contrast between Yaakov and Yosef is striking. Both used the exact same words, “Am I instead of G-d?”, but their responses were very different. Yaakov used the expression to rebuke his dear wife Rochel who was suffering, while Yosef used it to comfort his brothers who were frightened.
This is the deeper message of the Midrash. Yaakov may have been correct in defending himself and explaining that he could not control Hashem's decision about Rochel having children. But being correct was not enough. He should also have recognized his wife's pain and responded with sensitivity.
Yosef, on the other hand, understood that his brothers were frightened and needed reassurance. Rather than focusing on whether their fears were justified, he focused on their emotional needs. He demonstrated that the appropriate response to someone who is suffering or frightened is not necessarily to explain why that person is wrong, but first to acknowledge the feelings behind the concern.
This is an important lesson for all of us. When someone expresses frustration, sadness, or fear, our natural inclination may be to explain why that person should not feel that way. We may believe that the person is misunderstanding the situation or reacting irrationally. But even when someone's feelings are not based on a correct understanding of the facts, those feelings are real to that person.
Sometimes the most helpful response is not to offer an explanation or prove that we are right. It is to listen, show understanding, and validate the other person's pain. Only after doing so can we hope to help that person see the situation differently.
We should strive to follow Yosef's example. In our marriages, our families, our friendships, and our communities, we must learn to put aside our instinct to defend ourselves and instead try to understand what the other person is experiencing. We should attempt to be more like Hashem and develop compassion and understanding for others, and in that way bring greater peace and harmony to our families, communities and to the entire world.





















Comments